Posted by Grace
We've had the most disappointing experience with Pottery Barn. I'm never ordering from them again, and I advise people to do their research before ordering from them as well.
For the first time in my life I am in a position to invest in quality furniture. I have family that have bought products from PB in the past. I have seen and felt this furniture with my own hands - it's sturdy and good quality. I expected that same level of quality in the products I purchased, but I was SORELY disappointed.
I ordered 3 products from the North Collection: the North Reclaimed Wood Platform Bed (king), the North Reclaimed Wood Extending Dining Table, and the North Reclaimed Wood Buffet. I ordered all of these products at the same time, in July of 2022. It wasn't until September when the first product arrived (the bed) - and that's when the nightmare started.
Below are the details of the problems with each product.
BED
1. The bed was irreparably damaged by the delivery people putting it together. They put it together wrong, in the process damaging the legs so much that they couldn't be attached. They didn't let us know - rather, they simply set them under the bed to appear as if they were attached, and we've had to deal with the aftermath
2. I followed up with PB and replacement parts were ordered, but upon delivery they were parts for totally different beds in different collections
3. I had to contact Pottery Barn about the wrong replacement parts and I was informed that replacement parts do not exist for the bed (which someone should have told me before ordering replacement parts). At that time a replacement bed order was put in, with an estimated delivery of mid December 2022
4. Mid December 2022 came and went, and I heard nothing from either Pottery Barn or Ryder Last Mile (the delivery service) about our bed delivery, so I reached out a couple different times to Ryder Last Mile inquiring the status. They told me that some pieces of the bed were supposed to be delivered but weren't. I then had to call Pottery Barn, who told me that the missing parts were in fact delivered to Ryder Last Mile, so I was hearing two different stories. Obviously the 2 companies haven't been talking to each other, and it was up to me to figure out the mess.
5. Another replacement order was put in for a new bed. By this time it was January 2023. Between the customer service issues and issues with the other PB products we ordered, we ultimately decided to return all the products.
6. On top of all of this, I found out I was pregnant around the time our bed first arrived. We hadn't been able to use the bed at all given the broken state, so the whole time this mess was in the works my husband and I were sleeping on a mattress on the floor in a different bedroom in our house. (Don't get me wrong - I've slept on plenty a mattress on the floor in my life, and I know that's an incredible blessing in itself - we are very fortunate and I know many many people aren't afforded the same luxury.) I'm just saying that it's not ideal given that we paid a lot of money for this bed that we should have been able to have been use upon delivery.
TABLE
1. Once the table arrived, we were sorely disappointed in the quality. It was wobbly, and the material felt light, cheap. Given that it's an extendable table, the table top wasn't thick - quite hollow to accommodate the leaves (which makes sense) but I have seen many an extendable table and that fact alone shouldn't limit it's sturdiness. You can have a solid, thick table that's still extendable. I think this ultimately had to do with the material. It was easy to wiggle - definitely not what we were looking for. We returned this product.
BUFFET
1. Once the buffet arrived, we were again sorely disappointed in the quality (nothing new given all our other experiences with our PB products!) The insertable shelves seemed a different color and material than the buffet body. They shelves were reddish and smooth, while the body of the buffet was a sort of gray hue with a rustic/rough finish. It didn't match very well. Additionally, the construction was shoddy and sloppy. I'd compare it to a product we ordered from Walmart that you put together yourself. Honestly, might get better quality from Walmart. The screws and nail holes were visible just inside the buffet. The cutouts for cords in the shelves were rough and uneven as well. Additionally, there was a scratch left on the top of the buffet.
2. This product had been sitting in our home for just one month before we noticed that 2 large cracks appeared on the right door, splitting it totally from left to right at the top of the door and the bottom of the door. Apparently the door cracked from the level of dryness in our home. It was an confirmation that the buffet was constructed poorly and made from subpar material. Quality furniture shouldn't just crack and break that easily. We returned this product.
If you can imagine it, the easiest part of our whole experience with Pottery Barn was the return process. Thankfully we received a full refund for all the products, and they were picked up fairly quickly and efficiently from our home. Everything else (order to delivery) was a complete nightmare. Something about Potter Barn has changed between the time my family members ordered their products and from when I ordered my products. My guess is that Pottery Barn switched suppliers at some point, opting for a cheaper option but deciding not to lower their prices any. If they are offering this kind of quality and service, their products should be SIGNIFICANTLY cheaper.
I also don't like the fact that PB doesn't have any public reviews available on their store site or their store facebook page. I have heard that quality and customer service issues with PB are abounding, but we can't see that unless we dig into external review websites like this one. I really wish I dug into reviews before ordering my products.